For buy and hold investors, some like to actively pick and choose individual assets to buy, while others prefer to invest in the entire market. But which is a better investment strategy? Similar to a cronut, the answer is simple, but may not be obvious.
Which Investment Style is Better: Passive or Active?
The Cronut is a pastry that combines together a croissant and a doughnut. It was invented by New York City pastry chef Dominique Ansel and is trademarked. You should try one if you ever visit NYC. 🙂 They cost $5 each. But you can also find cronut knockoffs in Mexico that are much cheaper than the real thing, so you don’t peso much. 😄
Anyway, why is this relevant to investing? Because much like a cronut, the better investing strategy between passive and active, is not one or the other, but both. 😀 By combining individually selected assets, and index funds into one single pot, we can create the ultimate investment portfolio. This takes advantage of low-cost index funds, while adding alpha (excess returns) in certain segments of our portfolio. 😉
So how can we implement this? First, we actively pick and choose specific investments in the areas that we have extensive knowledgeable about. Then use the passive investing method to buy index funds for all other asset classes that we have insufficient knowledge about.
For example, I selected individual farms to buy in 2012/2013 because I knew how to look at soil quality, flood risk, earnings potential, etc. Therefore, I knew how to find undervalued land. Historically speaking higher quality farms appreciate faster than lower quality ones so I made sure to only buy farms above a certain quality. Farmland funds however, invest in all quality land. As a result I have outperformed every farmland or agricultural based ETF I could find on the stock market. So within the context of this asset class, passive investing would not have done me any good.
On the other hand, when I decided to get into the United Kingdom stock market last year, I decided to buy a low-cost stock market ETF. European stocks are beyond my comfort zone. I wasn’t about to perform due diligence on all 250 stocks of the FTSE 250 index. So that’s why I invested in a broad market UK index fund instead which contains those 250 individual stocks. 🙂
This is why self knowledge is very important for investors. We should try to use our strengths and specific knowledge to produce better than average outcomes in certain types of industries or asset classes. Then we can aim for average market returns in all other areas that we do not understand. Overall, this should give us a higher investment return than either a completely passive approach (which will give us average market returns), or a completely active approach (which will most likely result in under-performing the market.)
But in order for this combined investment approach to succeed we have to know the limits of our knowledge and capabilities.